Addressing the Indian Chamber of Commerce in Kolkata

November 23, 2017

“Since 1959, as refugees,” he told them, “we Tibetans have been able to reveal our culture to the world. Wherever we live, whether we’re in India, Europe, Australia or America, we have maintained our identity and shared in the spirit of being Tibetan. Those of us who live in the free world represent those who live in Tibet. I’m grateful to all Tibetans for keeping that spirit alive.

His Holiness the Dalai Lama addressing members of the Tibetan community in Kolkata, India on November 23, 2017. Photo by Tenzin Choejor
His Holiness the Dalai Lama addressing members of the Tibetan community in Kolkata, India on November 23, 2017. Photo by Tenzin Choejor

“Soon after we arrived in India, with the help of the Government of India, we set up schools for our children. After that, in the settlements in South India, we re-established our centres of learning where we have upheld the Nalanda Tradition, which was brought to us by Shantarakshita in the 8th century and Atisha in the 11th, both of whom hailed from where we are now, Bengal. One of the features of the Nalanda Tradition is its reliance on reason and logic. Indeed, the Buddha advised, ‘O monks, just as the wise test gold by burning, cutting and rubbing, Examine my words thoroughly And accept them only after you have investigated them—not just out of respect for me’.”

His Holiness emphasized the value of the Tibetan language as a means of accurately expressing the psychology, reason and logic of what the Buddha taught. He reminded his listeners that it is the language of the Kangyur and Tengyur, the body of largely Buddhist literature translated from Sanskrit.

As he prepared to lead a simple ceremony for generating the awakening mind of bodhichitta, His Holiness explained that when it comes to the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha, it is essential to understand what the Dharma is. On that basis it will be possible to better understand the Buddha and the Sangha. He said that to understand the Dharma you have to have some idea what is meant by emptiness. Not just a nihilistic idea, what it means is that whatever exists arises in dependence on other factors and therefore is empty of intrinsic existence. This corresponds to quantum physics stating that things have no objective existence.

Members of the Tibetan community listening to His Holiness the Dalai Lama speaking during their meeting in Kolkata, India on November 23, 2017. Photo by Tenzin Choejor
Members of the Tibetan community listening to His Holiness the Dalai Lama speaking during their meeting in Kolkata, India on November 23, 2017. Photo by Tenzin Choejor

His Holiness encouraged the students in the audience not to forget their Tibetan but to make an effort to keep it up. He recommended that they pay attention to Buddhist philosophy and psychology in an academic way, not necessarily from a religious point of view.

The Buddha taught the two truths, conventional and ultimate, which concern the gap between appearance and reality. When, in the ‘Heart Sutra’ it says ‘form is empty’, it means form has no intrinsic or inherent existence. It exists in dependence on other factors. On the basis of these Two Truths, the Buddha taught the Four Noble Truths concerning suffering and its origin, cessation and the path to it. His Holiness remarked that he made this clear in one of the verses of the Praise to the Seventeen Masters of Nalanda:

By understanding the meaning of the two truths, the way things exist,
We ascertain through the four truths how we arrive in and how we leave the cycle of existence.
Engendered by valid cognition, our faith in the three refuges will be firm.
May I be blessed to establish the root of the path to liberation.

On this occasion His Holiness came to Kolkata at the invitation of the Indian Chamber of Commerce (ICC). An audience of 250 members and invited guests made him welcome. Once he had lit the inaugural lamp, he sat down to speak to them.

His Holiness the Dalai Lama lighting an lamp to open his talk to members of the Indian Chamber of Commerce in Kolkata, India on November 23, 2017. Photo by Tenzin Choejor
His Holiness the Dalai Lama lighting an lamp to open his talk to members of the Indian Chamber of Commerce in Kolkata, India on November 23, 2017. Photo by Tenzin Choejor

“I always start my talks by greeting the audience as brothers and sisters, because that’s how I feel about all 7 billion human beings alive today. Each of us was born from our mother and then basked in her affection. That’s the seed that enables us to show affection to others. Scientists observe that our basic human nature is compassionate. As social animals, we all have a sense of compassion, but it tends to lie dormant. We need a sense of the oneness of humanity, a sense that we are all like brothers and sisters, to awaken it. As a human being, I am committed to encouraging people to appreciate this.

“As a Buddhist monk, I am committed to fostering religious harmony. India is a vivid example that religious traditions can live together. Indigenous traditions like the Samkhyas, Jains, varieties of Hinduism, Buddhism and later Sikhism, have for centuries lived in peace alongside Zoroastrianism, Judaism, Christianity and Islam, which are traditions that originated elsewhere.

“As a Tibetan, I have retired from temporal responsibility since we elected leaders in 2001 ns 2011. I have also put an end to Dalai Lamas occupying such a position in the future. Because the custom is related to feudalism, it’s out of date and time to change it. Incidentally, I feel the same about the caste system, the classification of some people as untouchable, while others are privileged. It too is out of date and undemocratic. It’s time it was changed.

His Holiness the Dalai Lama addressing members of the Indian Chamber of Commerce in Kolkata, India on November 23, 2017. Photo by Tenzin Choejor
His Holiness the Dalai Lama addressing members of the Indian Chamber of Commerce in Kolkata, India on November 23, 2017. Photo by Tenzin Choejor

“Anyway, I am committed to drawing attention to the need to protect the natural environment of the Tibetan Plateau. This is of importance not only to Tibetans, but also to the 1 billion people across Asia who depend for their water supply on rivers that rise in Tibet.

“In addition, I’m concerned about keeping our Tibetan cultural heritage alive. In the past you Indians were our Gurus and Tibetans were your chelas or students. What we learned from you about philosophy and psychology, about the workings of the mind and emotions, and the uses of reason and logic, remains relevant and helpful in the world today.”

His Holiness explained his conviction that the world is facing a moral crisis. Many of the problems we face today come about because we lack moral principles—we lack compassion. One reason for this is that modern education is oriented to material goals with little time for inner values. He suggested that if we really believed that other human beings were like our brothers and sisters, we couldn’t let children die of starvation, nor stand by while people killed each other as they do today.

Members of the audience listening to His Holiness the Dalai Lama speaking in Kolkata, India on November 23, 2017. Photo by Tenzin Choejor
Members of the audience listening to His Holiness the Dalai Lama speaking in Kolkata, India on November 23, 2017. Photo by Tenzin Choejor

He observed that knowledge of how to deal with the root of such problems by tackling our negative emotions already exists in this country. His Holiness places great hope on India’s ability to combine modern education with its ancient understanding of the workings of the mind and emotions.

“Consequently,” he declared, “I will dedicate the rest of my life to reviving an understanding of India’s ancient knowledge in this country and trying to promote it through education.”

The audience smiled in appreciation as they applauded His Holiness’s words.

His answers to questions they asked touched on artificial intelligence and his doubt that it would overtake human intelligence. He further remarked that if the 21st century were to be more peaceful than the century that preceded it, it will be necessary to move beyond old ways of thinking, to forgo the inclination to meet problems and conflicts with a use of force. A more humane approach is required. This accords with India’s longstanding tradition of ahimsa or non-violence. He suggested that a long term target should be a demilitarized world. “It won’t happen in a hurry,” he said, “but it’s what we should aim for.”

A member of the audience asking His Holiness the Dalai Lama a question during his talk in Kolkata, India on November 23, 2017. Photo by Tenzin Choejor
A member of the audience asking His Holiness the Dalai Lama a question during his talk in Kolkata, India on November 23, 2017. Photo by Tenzin Choejor

His Holiness noted that in an increasingly globalised world, national boundaries have less significance than they did. He reported California Governor Jerry Brown’s telling him that national boundaries are nowhere to be seen when this blue planet is viewed from space. He reiterated his admiration for the spirit of the European Union, the placing of a common European interest before that of individual states. He cited the fact that, in a historical precedent, peace has prevailed amongst members of the EU over the last 70 years.

Asked how to apply the Buddha’s advice in modern life, His Holiness recalled a conversation with a Swami in Bangalore in which they agreed that Buddhist and Hindu traditions have ethics, concentration and wisdom—shila, shamatha and vipashyana—in common. They may differ on their stance towards atman and anatman, but that is a matter of personal practice. Many Indian traditions involve an inner transformation that His Holiness has described as cultivating emotional hygiene.

Whereas there is evidence that constant anger, hatred and fear undermine our immune systems, warm-heartedness and a compassionate outlook bring a smile to the face.

His Holiness the Dalai Lama speaking to over 250 members and guests of the Indian Chamber of Commerce in Kolkata, India on November 23, 2017. Photo by Tenzin Choejor
His Holiness the Dalai Lama speaking to over 250 members and guests of the Indian Chamber of Commerce in Kolkata, India on November 23, 2017. Photo by Tenzin Choejor

After the formal words of thanks, His Holiness had a few final words for the audience.

“Don’t think there isn’t much you can do. Change always begins with an inspired individual, who then influences ten others, who in turn may influence ten more—that’s how ideas spread and change comes about.”

Shortly afterwards, having eaten a quick lunch, His Holiness drove to Kolkata airport to fly to Delhi, from where tomorrow he will return to Dharamsala.